Home

About
Us

Centers

Research
Fellows

Authors

Board
of Directors

Board
of Advisors

Staff

What
Others are Saying About Us

The
Alexis De Tocqueville Award

Awards

The
Lighthouse Logo

Employment
Opportunities

Contact
Information

Map and
Directions

Blogs

The
Beacon

MyGovCost
News & Blog

Issues

Agriculture

Antitrust,
Competition, and Monopoly

Banking
and Finance

Bureaucracy
and Government

Business

Campaign
Finance Reform

Civil
Liberties/ Human Rights

Collectivism

Constitutional
Law

Corporate
Welfare

Crime

Culture/
Society

Defense
and Foreign Policy

Democracy

Diplomacy
and Foreign Aid

Drugs
(Illicit)

Economic
History and Development (International)

Economic
History and Development (U.S.)

Economic
Policy

Economists

Education

Energy

Entertainment

Environment

Family

Fiscal
Policy

Free
Market Economics

Free
Speech

Freedom

Government
Power

Government
Secrecy

Government
Waste/Pork

Gun
Control

Health
Care

History
(International)

History
(U.S)

Housing

Immigration

Labor
and Employment

Land
Use

Latin
America

Law
Enforcement

Litigation

Nationalism

Political
Ideology and Philosophy

Politics

Privacy

Privatization

Property
Rights

Public
Choice Theory

Public
Health/ Consumer Protection

Race
Issues

Regulation
and Deregulation

Religion

Science

Social
Security

Taxation

Technology

Terrorism
and National Crises

Trade

Transportation

Urban
Issues

Welfare

Women's
Issues

Newsroom

Commentary
Articles

In
The News

News
Releases

Experts

Multimedia

Video

Audio

Events

Upcoming
and Recent Events

Past
Events

Audio
and Video

Transcripts

Buy
Event Materials

Publications

Books

The
Independent Review (Quarterly Journal)

Policy
Reports

The
Lighthouse (E-mail Newsletter)

Commentary
Articles

News
Releases

Audio and
Visual Programs

The
Independent (Quarterly Newsletter)

Research
Articles

Working
Papers

Text
Adoption Program

Centers

Center
on Culture and Civil Society

Center on
Educational Excellence

Center on
Entrepreneurial Innovation

Center on
Global Prosperity

Center
on Health and the Environment

Center
on Law and Justice

Center
On Peace and Liberty

Students

Independent
Scholarship Fund

Templeton
Fellowships Essay Contest

Summer
Seminars

Student
Internships

Store

Institute
Books

Non-Institute
Books

Forthcoming
Books

Subscribe
to The Independent Review

Order
Back Issues of The Independent Review

Event
Ticket Reservations

Event
Audio and Video

Policy
Reports

Donate

The Government Is the Problem

By Randall
Holcombe | Tuesday November 15, 2011 at 2:06 PM PST

Ronald Reagan said “Government is not the solution to our problems,
government is the problem.”  Nowhere does this appear more true than with
the state of the global economy today.  My fellow blogger Robert Higgs has
repeatedly emphasized the government creation of regime uncertainty that keeps
unemployment high and investment low, because businesses are reluctant to hire
and invest when uncertain government policies can make those decisions more
costly in the future.  Even more directly, the world-wide economic
instability caused by the budgetary excesses in Greece, Italy, and other
Eurozone countries hinders global recovery.  Meanwhile, the unsustainable
deficits in the United States have become so obvious that even people in
Congress are aware of them!  The Congressional Deficit Reduction Super
Committee will make its report to Congress on November 23... if they can reach
an agreement.

President Reagan made the general observation that government is the problem,
but more specifically on the subject above, government is creating economic
instability, not reducing it.  Meanwhile, the conventional economic wisdom,
both among many professional economists and among politicians, is that
government should intervene more to stabilize the economy.  Christina Romer says the Federal Reserve has not been
aggressive enough in their stimulus efforts, and numerous commentators, led by Paul Krugman, say we need more stimulus spending.

Yes, there are economists who argue differently.  I’m one of them.
It appears to me that those who are arguing for more government intervention are
saying “This didn’t work before, so let’s try more of it.”  There are
reasons these interventions haven’t worked.  The more government takes out
of the economy, the less will be left for private sector production.  The
more uncertainty government produces, the less businesses are willing to hire
and invest.

Government stimulus efforts, which have thus far shown no evidence that they
work, are meanwhile burdening us with budget deficits in excess of a trillion
dollars a year, and a national debt approaching $15 trillion.  That is a
lot to pay for something that doesn’t work.

I am disappointed in my profession — the economics profession — for not
seeing more clearly that government is not stabilizing the economy, it is
creating instability.  This points to fundamental problems in mainstream
methodology.  Economists tend to depict citizens as mathematical functions
who react to situations in a predictable and repeatable way, and government as
an omniscient benevolent dictator that knows the optimal course of action, and
follows it.  Once these unrealistic assumptions are stripped away, the idea
that the government is a stabilizing force on the economy vanishes with
them.

Tags: Bailouts, Budget and Tax Policy, Economics, Politics, Uncategorized

2 Comment(s)

The Obama Team claims that the stimulus “saved or created” 3.3 million
jobs. How do they know? I can reveal their method, as presented by Christina
Romer, recently resigned head of the President’s Council of Economic
Advisors.

Consider this analogy to the idiotic logic of our government
economists.

Say that records from my backyard grill parties show that on average, 20
guests eat 25 hamburgers and 5 hot dogs. I would like to be much more popular,
so I double the food to 50 hamburgers and 10 hot dogs for my next party. I
expect 40 people to show up without calling more friends.

After a few more parties, I find that 23 people (three more) do show up.
Maybe they came because they heard about the huge amount of food. I resolve to
supply even more food (stimulus) for my next parties.

Government economists are treating the entire population of the US in the
same way that my example treats grill parties. You may say that I am unfairly
criticizing government economists. They couldn’t be that simplistic and
stupid. But, that is exactly the method they used to recommend “stimulus” and
estimate new jobs.

–> Romer is Theoretically Correct

The President’s Council Of Economic Advisers in May 2009 [edited]:
===
===
To estimate the likely impact of the fiscal stimulus on real GDP, we
used multipliers that we feel represent a consensus of a broad range of
economists and professional forecasters.

The final step is to take the effect on GDP and translate it into job
creation. Not all of the increased output reflects increased employment: some
comes from increases in hours of work among employed workers and some comes
from higher productivity.

We therefore use the relatively conservative rule of thumb that a 1 percent
increase in GDP corresponds to an increase in employment of approximately 1
million jobs, or about three-quarters of a percent. This has been the rough
correspondence over history and matches the Federal Reserve Bank model
reasonably well.
=== ===

1: Measure the number of jobs in the economy at different levels of
GDP. Notice the ratio 1MM jobs per 1% of GDP.
2: Spend money. Each
dollar spent adds to GDP by definition.
3: Welcome the newly
employed people to the economy.

This is idiocy. This is mere formula crunching. First, express the
complexity of the US economy as a simple ratio. Then, play with the ratio by
manipulating an accounting measure (the definition of GDP).

Of course, they do get to distribute a huge amount of money to their
friends along the way. So, it isn’t all bad, for them.

Andrew_M_Garland | Nov
16, 2011 | Reply

It’s a bit like the anaology I once read from C.S. Lewis. He wrote about an
Irishman who bought a wood stove in order to save money on his utlity bills.
It seemd to work. He found that his bills were cut in half. He then concluded
that if he bought another wood stove he would never have to pay another
utility bill during his lifetime.

Phil Dillon | Nov
16, 2011 | Reply

Post a Comment

Name (required)

E-mail (will not be published) (required)

Website

Next Post »

« Previous Post

Search

Also Available

Free Email Updates

Authors

Alvaro Vargas
Llosa (1)

Angel Martin (1)

Anthony Gregory
(263)

Art Carden (58)

Benjamin Powell
(2)

Carl Close (60)

David Beito (101)

David Theroux
(150)

Edward Lopez (6)

Emily Skarbek
(5)

Gabriel Gasave
(2)

Ivan Eland
(1)

James A. Montanye
(2)

James L. Payne
(5)

Jeffrey Rogers Hummel
(1)

Jonathan Bean (98)

Josh Kaplan (2)

Karen
Kwiatkowski (9)

Lindsay Boyd (11)

Mary Theroux
(133)

Melancton Smith
(23)

Paul Theroux (1)

Peter Klein (69)

Ralph Raico (1)

Randall Holcombe
(147)

Robert Higgs
(232)

Roland de Beque
(1)

Vern McKinley
(1)

Wendy Honett
(11)

William Shughart
(47)

William Watkins
(6)

New Books

Free
Shipping On Orders Over $60! (Within U.S.A.)

THE
CIVILIAN AND THE MILITARY: A History of the American Antimilitarist
Tradition
By Arthur
A. Ekirch, Jr.

SECURING
CIVIL RIGHTS: Freedmen, the Fourteenth Amendment, and the Right to Bear
Arms
By Stephen
P. Halbrook

THE
NEW HOLY WARS: Economic Religion vs. Environmental Religion in
Contemporary America
By Robert
H. Nelson

HOUSING
AMERICA: Building Out of a Crisis
Edited by Randall
G. Holcombe, Benjamin
Powell

RACE
AND LIBERTY IN AMERICA: The Essential Reader
Edited by Jonathan
J. Bean

THE
DECLINE OF AMERICAN LIBERALISM
By Arthur
A. Ekirch, Jr.

PARTITIONING
FOR PEACE: An Exit Strategy for Iraq
By Ivan
Eland

DEPRESSION,
WAR, AND COLD WAR: Challenging the Myths of Conflict and
Prosperity
By Robert
Higgs

RECARVING
RUSHMORE: Ranking the Presidents on Peace, Prosperity, and
Liberty
By Ivan
Eland

THE
FOUNDERS’ SECOND AMENDMENT: Origins of the Right to Bear
Arms
By Stephen
P. Halbrook

THE
CHE GUEVARA MYTH: And the Future of Liberty
By Alvaro
Vargas Llosa

More
Books

Categories

Select Category Afghanistan Africa Agriculture
American History Art Audio Austrian School of
economics Bailouts Books Budget
and Tax Policy Business
California Canada Censorship Charity China
CIA Civil Liberties Civil
Society Conservatism
Constitution Corporatism Corruption Criminal
Justice Culture Defense Disaster Management Drugs Economics
Education Elections Employment Energy
England Entertainment Entrepreneurship Environment Europe Family
Fascism FBI Federal
Reserve Food Free Market Georgia Germany
Global Warming Government subsidies Great Depression Gun
Control Healthcare Housing Humor Immigration
Imperialism Inflation Insurance Integrity Intellectual
Property Intelligence
agency Iran Iraq Japan Labor
Land use Latin America Law
Liberalism Liberty Libya
Media Mercantilism Middle
East Military Money and Banking Monopoly and Antitrust Morality Nanny
State Nationalism Nationalization Natural Law Nuclear
Weapons Pakistan Peace Personal Liberty Philosophy Police Politics
Poverty Power Presidential
Power Price control
Privacy Privatization Propaganda Property
Rights Racism Regulation Religion Russia
Science Social Security Socialism Sports Surveillance Taxation Technology Terrorism The
State Torture Trade Transparency Transportation Uncategorized Unemployment United
Nations Upcoming Events
Urban Issues Utilitarianism Video War Weapons Welfare

Recent Posts

Insider
Trading by Representative Spencer Bachus

The
Government Is the Problem

Mario
Vargas Llosa and the Search for Liberty

Why
I Voted “No” to a Strike

More
“Green” Energy Cronyism and Corporate Welfare

Biodefense
Cronyism and Corporate Welfare

Armistice
Day

One
of Reagan’s Greatest Acts on Behalf of American Freedom

U.S.
Economic Recovery Remains Anemic, at Best

Greek
Referendum on the Bailout: Good Idea!

Archives
Select Month
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011 April 2011 March 2011 February 2011 January 2011 December 2010 November 2010 October 2010 September 2010 August 2010 July 2010 June 2010 May 2010 April 2010 March 2010 February 2010 January 2010 December 2009 November 2009 October 2009 September 2009 August 2009 July 2009 June 2009 May 2009 April 2009 March 2009 February 2009 January 2009 December 2008 November 2008 October 2008 September 2008 August 2008 July 2008 June 2008 May 2008 April 2008 March 2008 February 2008 January 2008 December 2007 November 2007 October 2007

Blogroll

(Tab)ulation,
The

Against
Monopoly

Agoraphilia

Alpha.Sources

Anything
Peaceful

Austrian
Addiction

But What the Hell Do I
Know...

http://www.cato-at-liberty.org/

Citizen Economists

Cobden Centre

Commons, The

Conservative
Economics

Coordination
Problem

Coyote Blog

Crash Landing

Culture of
Congestion

Division of Labor

Econ Policy
Journal

EconLog

Economic Way of Thinking,
The

Economics and
History

Economics in Plain
English

Ed Policy

El Instituto Independiente
Blog

Enterprise Blog, The

Federalist

Financial
Armageddon

First Principles
Journal

Fly Bottle, The

Foundry, The

Freakonomics

Free Advice from Bob
Murphy

Free
Banking

Free
Exchange

Freedom Talks

Front Porch
Republic

Greg Mankiw's Blog

Hawblog

Healthcare
Economist

Imaginative
Conservative, The

Jeff Miron

John Stossel's
Take

Kids Prefer Cheese

Knowledge Problem

Krugman-in-Wonderland

Libertarian
Standard

Macro and Other Market
Musings

Managerial Econ

Market Urbanism

Maverecon

Megan
McArdle

Mess That Greenspan Made, The

Mises Economics Blog

Money Illusion, The

Neutral Source

Newmark's
Door

No Coercion

OpenMarket

Organizations and
Markets

Perfect Substitute,
The

Perpetual Three-Dot
Column, The

Peter Gordon

PowerBlog

Private Sector
Development Blog

Rogue Economist
Rants

Skeptical
CPA

Stefan Karlsson

Straus
Military Reform Project

ThinkMarkets

University
Bookman

More Books

Free
Shipping On Orders Over $60! (Within U.S.A.)

LESSONS
FROM THE POOR: Triumph of the Entrepreneurial
Spirit
Edited by Alvaro
Vargas Llosa

GOOD
MONEY: Birmingham Button Makers, the Royal Mint, and the Beginnings of
Modern Coinage, 1775-1821
By George
Selgin

THE
EMPIRE HAS NO CLOTHES: U.S. Foreign Policy Exposed
By Ivan
Eland

MAKING
POOR NATIONS RICH: Entrepreneurship and the Process of Economic
Development
Edited by Benjamin
Powell

OPPOSING
THE CRUSADER STATE: Alternatives to Global
Interventionism
Edited by Carl
P. Close, Robert
Higgs

NEITHER
LIBERTY NOR SAFETY: Fear, Ideology, and the Growth of
Government
By Robert
Higgs

ANARCHY
AND THE LAW: The Political Economy of Choice
Edited by Edward
P. Stringham

ELECTRIC
CHOICES: Deregulation and the Future of Electric
Power
Edited by Andrew
N. Kleit

TWILIGHT
WAR: The Folly of U.S. Space Dominance
By Mike
Moore

AMERICAN
HEALTH CARE: Government, Market Processes and the Public
Interest
Edited by Roger
D. Feldman

More
Books

Stats

Total Stats

29 Authors

1,450 Posts

9,393 Comments

3,140 Comment Posters

70 Links

10 Most Commented Posts

Partisan
Politics—A Fool’s Game for the Masses - 110 comments

Consent
of the Governed? - 108 comments

Ticking
Time Bomb Explodes, Public Is Shocked - 91 comments

Killing
a Man Does Not Testify to National Greatness - 89 comments

What’s
the Point of Demonstrating? - 87 comments

Stephen
Halbrook with CNN’s Lou Dobbs on Gun Control - 82 comments

TSA Thugs -
79 comments

Defense
Spending Is Much Greater than You Think - 78 comments

Democracy’s
Most Critical Defect - 69 comments

The
Continuing Puzzle of the Hyperinflation that Hasn’t Occurred - 66
comments

November 2011

S

M

T

W

T

F

S

« Oct

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

29

30

Copyright 2011 The Independent Institute